Article

Transportation budget passes Ohio Senate

Community Solutions Team
Transforming data into progress
Additional Contributors
No items found.
March 25, 2019
Read time:
Download Fact Sheets
Register now
Share this resource
Subscribe to our Newsletter
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download this as a PDF

By: Sam Sobul, Public Policy and External Affairs Intern

William Tarter Jr., Public Policy and External Affairs Associate

What Happened

The substitute transportation budget introduced by the Ohio Senate Transportation, Commerce and Workforce Committee was amended Thursday and passed out of the committee on a 6-5 vote. It was approved by the Ohio Senate 24-6. The Senate version of the transportation budget, also known as Substitute House Bill 62, changed the amount of a proposed gas tax increase, as well as the amount of money given to public transportation. The new bill reduces the House’s gas tax increase proposal of 10.7 cents per gallon over two years for gasoline and 20 cents per gallon over three years for diesel, to 6 cents per gallon for both gasoline and diesel beginning July 1.

 While no organizations argued for decreasing the funding, some did argue that the transportation budget, which is primarily supported by the gas tax, was the wrong place to find money for public transit.

The amount earmarked for public transit was also reduced. In the House version of the bill, public transportation received $100 million from Federal Highway Administration “flex” dollars. This would be in addition to the $6.5 million that comes from the General Revenue Fund, which is included in the state operating budget (introduced last week). In the Senate version, all money for public transit is removed from the Transportation Budget, and $55 million would be included in the state’s operating budget. The $55 million number was the final number that the Senate agreed to. The Senate Transportation Committee initially passed $40 million and $8.5 million was added to that in an amendment by Senator Matt Dolan. This is in addition to the $6.5 million currently allocated. The fact that the money is coming entirely from the state operating budget is significant, because that $55 million amount would mean public transit funding must compete with other programs from across the state for the same dollars. This will be discussed later in this blog post.

Other Changes

The Senate also included several other changes in the bill, only a few of which will be mentioned here. The proposed registration fees for hybrid and electric vehicles have been reduced by $25, to $175 and $75, respectively, but those changes will not go into effect until January 1. The Senate also changed the proposed formula to charge a tax for those who use Compressed Natural Gas (CNG). This tax would be phased in over five years. The Senate transportation budget would end the Financial Responsibility Random Verification Program on June 30. We previously wrote about this program here. It randomly selects 5,400 people each week and sends them a letter requiring proof of vehicle insurance. If proof is not provided, the person’s driver’s license is suspended. There is evidence that these suspensions disproportionately affect poor Ohioans. Finally, the Senate passed language which would increase the earned income tax credit (EITC) from 10 percent to 30 percent, as a well as remove a mechanism that limits the credit to not more than 50 percent of the taxpayer's tax liability if the taxpayer's Ohio adjusted gross income exceeds $20,000.[1] This is expected to reduce the gas tax impact on lower income Ohioans and would reduce tax income to the state by $38 million annually.

The Process

These changes came after the Ohio Senate’s Transportation, Commerce and Workforce Committee held six days of formal hearings, and some informal hearings the week before, on the transportation budget that passed the Ohio House of Representatives on March 7. The remainder of this post will discuss the arguments made by those who testified in front of the Senate before the newest version of this bill was introduced.  

The bulk of the testimony on the gas tax was in favor of increasing it to the 18 cents per gallon on gasoline and diesel that was initially included in the executive transportation budget, this is in contrast to the proposed decrease we have seen in the House and Senate passed versions of the budget. The organizations that testified in favor of the increase argued that this tax hike was the bare minimum necessary for Ohio to construct, maintain and expand its road and bridge infrastructure. Noticeably, not a single organization that testified before the Senate introduced its version were in favor of lowering the tax on gasoline, despite that being the end result. There were, however, a few organizations that testified that the diesel rate should not be raised to the extent included in the House bill. These organizations argued that the increased diesel costs would be passed along to consumers and could raise the costs of transportation for small businesses throughout the state. Another handful of organizations submitted testimony that the proposed fees on hybrid and electric vehicles were too high. They argued that, since hybrid vehicles still use gas and pay the gas tax, it is unfair to also charge them a $100 registration fee. Additionally, testimony was provided saying that the proposed $200 fee on electric vehicles would amount to a higher “user fee” than the average driver would pay under the gas tax, with Clean Fuels Ohio arguing that, by its calculations, a $96/year registration fee for electric vehicles would be more reasonable. Finally, two organizations argued that the House provision, which implemented a tax on CNG in line with the diesel fuel tax should be phased in, rather than jumping from 0 to 28 cents per gallon immediately, as it would do under the House bill. The Senate version does not change the rate, but does change how CNG is measured for the purposes of this tax.

Public Transportation

Similarly, none of the testimony regarding public transit spending argued that the amount should be less than $100 million in federal “flex” dollars that were included in the House bill. Indeed, while the $100 million is more than twice what DeWine initially requested ($40 million), several organizations testified that, based on a transit needs survey done in 2015, the state needs to fund public transit at a rate of $185 million per year. Additionally, the $100 million from the House bill is entirely for capital projects, not operational costs. The $55 million dedicated to public transit would have flexibility to be used for operating costs or capital projects, and could be subject to debate in the operating budget process. Several of the organizations arguing for an increase in public transit spending in this budget also favor finding a dedicated source of funding for public transit outside of what is earmarked for infrastructure.  

While no organizations argued for decreasing the funding, some did argue that the transportation budget, which is primarily supported by the gas tax, was the wrong place to find money for public transit. Both the Ohio Department of Transportation and the Ohio Contractors Association stated that, since even an 18 cent per gallon increase in the fuel tax will barely cover expenses for roads and bridges, paying for public transit out of federal flex funds will make the shortfall significant. This shortfall would become even more pronounced if the gas tax amount that is approved is significantly less than the original 18 cents recommended by DeWine.

Next Steps

Since the transportation budget is required to be signed into law by March 31, waiting until March 21 until the Senate passed its version of the budget will give the General Assembly just 10 days to complete the process. The remaining steps at this point include having a conference committee to create a bill that reconciles the differences between the House and Senate versions, have that bill pass both the House and the Senate and then get signed by the governor. The DeWine administration is in favor of a much larger gas tax increase than is in either version of the transportation budget. Some legislators have expressed concern that if the increase that comes out of conference committee is too low, DeWine won’t sign the bill, forcing the process to start over. As a result, Speaker of the House Larry Householder has stated that the House “has things prepared” in the event that a short-term funding solution is needed.[2]  

If you would like to read any of the testimony given in the Senate on the transportation budget, it can be found here: http://www.ohiosenate.gov/committees/transportation-commerce-and-workforce/document-archive  

[1]LSC, Page 44. https://www.lsc.ohio.gov/documents/budget/133/transportation/SR/comparedoc-hb62-sr.pdf  

[2] http://hannah.com/Hannah/NewsStory.aspx?id=212542

Download Fact Sheets

District 10

Download

All Council Districts 2024

Download

District 4

Download

District 2

Download

District 11

Download

District 9

Download

District 8

Download

District 5

Download

District 7

Download

District 1

Download

District 3

Download

District 6

Download

West Boulevard

Download

University

Download

Union-Miles

Download

Tremont

Download

Stockyards

Download

St.Clair-Superior

Download

Old Brooklyn

Download

Ohio City

Download

North Shore Collinwood

Download

Mount Pleasant

Download

Lee-Seville

Download

Lee-Harvard

Download

Kinsman

Download

Kamm's Corners

Download

Jefferson

Download

Goodrich-Kirtland Park

Download

Glenville

Download

Fairfax

Download

Euclid-Green

Download

Edgewater

Download

Downtown

Download

Detroit Shoreway

Download

Cudell

Download

Collinwood-Nottingham

Download

Clark-Fulton

Download

Central

Download

Buckeye-Woodhill

Download

Buckeye-Shaker Square

Download

Brooklyn Centre

Download

Broadway-Slavic Village

Download

Bellaire-Puritas

Download

All Neighborhoods 2024

Download

West Boulevard Factsheet

Download

University Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Union-Miles Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Tremont Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Stockyards Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

St. Clair-Superior Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Old Brooklyn Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Ohio City Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

North Shore Collinwood Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Mount Pleasant Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Lee-Seville Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Lee-Harvard Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Kinsman Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Kamm's Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Jefferson Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Hough Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Hopkins Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Goodrich-Kirtland Park Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Glenville Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Fairfax Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Euclid-Green Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Edgewater Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Downtown Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Detroit Shoreway Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Cuyahoga Valley Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Cudell Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Collinwood-Nottingham Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Clark-Fulton Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Central Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Buckeye-Shaker Square Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Brooklyn Centre Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Broadway-Slavic Village Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Bellaire-Puritas Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

All Neighborhoods 2016

Download

District 2

Download

District 1

Download

Ohio Women Statewide

Download

All Women Fact Sheets

Download

Wyandot Women

Download

Wood Women

Download

Williams Women

Download

Wayne Women

Download

Washington Women

Download

Warren Women

Download

Vinton Women

Download

Van Wert Women

Download

Union Women

Download

Tuscarawas Women

Download

Trumbell Women

Download

Summit Women

Download

Stark Women

Download

Shelby Women

Download

Seneca Women

Download

Scioto Women

Download

Sandusky Women

Download
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download report

Subscribe to our newsletter

5 Things you need to know arrives on Mondays with the latest articles, events, and advocacy developments in Ohio

Explore the fact sheets

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

No Related Fact Sheets

Explore Topics

Browse articles, research, and testimony.